Single Game Records · Wheaton Football History

Total Offense

Every era since 1914 · as published by Wheaton College Athletics

Total Offense · Single-Game Records

Official

Record	Mark	Player	Game
Total Offense Yards	503	Tim Hardy	vs. Illinois Wesleyan, 10/24/98

Passing

Every era since 1914 · as published by Wheaton College Athletics

Passing · Single-Game Records

Official

Record	Mark	Player	Game
Pass Attempts	75	Keith Bishop	vs. Millikin, 9/14/85
Completions	42	Keith Bishop	vs. Millikin, 9/14/85
Passing Yards	506	Keith Bishop	vs. Millikin, 11/12/83
Touchdown Passes	6	Keith Bishop	vs. Carroll, 10/15/83; vs. North Park, 10/12/85
Touchdown Passes	6	Garrett Meador	vs. Albion, 9/10/11
Touchdown Passes	6	Luke Anthony	vs. Aurora, 11/20/21
Touchdown Passes	6	Ben Thorson	vs. Carroll, 10/22/23
Touchdown Passes	6	Mark Forcucci	vs. North Park, 11/15/25
Completion Pct.	.944	Sean Norris	vs. North Park, 10/4/08 (17-18)
Consecutive Completions	17	Jordan Roberts	vs. Carthage, 10/6/2013
Longest TD Pass	98	Keith Bishop to David Lauber	vs. North Central, 9/21/85

Passing Yards

1997–2025

#	Player	Yds	Game	Detail
1	Tim Hardy	462	Oct 24 1998 vs Illinois Wesleyan University	Att 39 · Cmp 23 · TD 3 · Int 1
2	Garrett Meador	438	Nov 12 2011 vs Millikin University	Att 45 · Cmp 31 · TD 5 · Int 1
3	Ben Thorson	402	Nov 25 2023 vs University of Wisconsin-Whitewater	Att 41 · Cmp 26 · TD 5 · Int 1
4	Ben Thorson	395	Sep 23 2023 vs Augustana College (IL)	Att 45 · Cmp 31 · TD 2 · Int 0
5	Garrett Meador	389	Oct 8 2011 vs Elmhurst University	Att 46 · Cmp 32 · TD 4 · Int 0
6	Josh Anderson	381	Oct 26 2002 vs Illinois Wesleyan University	Att 51 · Cmp 26 · TD 4 · Int 3
7	Jordan Roberts	380	Nov 3 2012 vs North Central College	Att 46 · Cmp 32 · TD 2 · Int 2
8	Mark Forcucci	378	Oct 18 2025 vs Carthage College	Att 23 · Cmp 20 · TD 5 · Int 1
9	Mark Forcucci	376	Nov 23 2024 vs University of Wisconsin-Stout	Att 31 · Cmp 23 · TD 2 · Int 0
10	Sean Norris	374	Nov 3 2007 vs Carthage College	Att 54 · Cmp 26 · TD 2 · Int 3

Top 10 of 25 ranked.

Touchdown Passes

1997–2025

#	Player	Touchdown Passes	Game	Detail
1	Garrett Meador	6	Sep 10 2011 vs Albion College	Att 31 · Cmp 23 · Yds 300 · Int 0
1	Luke Anthony	6	Nov 20 2021 vs Aurora University	Att 23 · Cmp 16 · Yds 233 · Int 0
1	Ben Thorson	6	Oct 21 2023 vs Carroll University	Att 28 · Cmp 22 · Yds 273 · Int 0
1	Mark Forcucci	6	Nov 15 2025 vs North Park University	Att 17 · Cmp 13 · Yds 282 · Int 1
5	Josh Anderson	5	Oct 13 2001 vs Carthage College	Att 29 · Cmp 19 · Yds 249 · Int 0
5	Jeremy Chupp	5	Sep 16 2006 vs WashU	Att 30 · Cmp 19 · Yds 228 · Int 1
5	Garrett Meador	5	Oct 29 2011 vs Augustana College (IL)	Att 36 · Cmp 26 · Yds 368 · Int 1
5	Garrett Meador	5	Nov 12 2011 vs Millikin University	Att 45 · Cmp 31 · Yds 438 · Int 1
5	Jordan Roberts	5	Oct 6 2012 vs Carthage College	Att 27 · Cmp 24 · Yds 258 · Int 0
5	Curtis McWilliams	5	Oct 6 2018 vs North Park University	Att 29 · Cmp 22 · Yds 285 · Int 1

Top 10 of 25 ranked.

Completions

1997–2025

#	Player	Completions	Game	Detail
1	Garrett Meador	32	Oct 8 2011 vs Elmhurst University	Att 46 · Yds 389 · TD 4 · Int 0
1	Jordan Roberts	32	Nov 3 2012 vs North Central College	Att 46 · Yds 380 · TD 2 · Int 2
3	Garrett Meador	31	Nov 12 2011 vs Millikin University	Att 45 · Yds 438 · TD 5 · Int 1
3	Ben Thorson	31	Sep 23 2023 vs Augustana College (IL)	Att 45 · Yds 395 · TD 2 · Int 0
5	Reece Butler	29	Sep 6 2014 vs Coe College	Att 42 · Yds 341 · TD 2 · Int 0
5	Luke Anthony	29	Dec 7 2019 vs Saint John's University	Att 40 · Yds 290 · TD 2 · Int 0
7	Andrew Bowers	28	Oct 1 2016 vs Illinois Wesleyan University	Att 35 · Yds 351 · TD 4 · Int 1
7	Johnny Peltz	28	Dec 3 2016 vs University of Mary Hardin-Baylor	Att 48 · Yds 284 · TD 2 · Int 3
7	Will Bowers	28	Oct 1 2022 vs North Central College	Att 37 · Yds 238 · TD 2 · Int 2
7	Will Bowers	28	Nov 5 2022 vs WashU	Att 38 · Yds 234 · TD 3 · Int 0

Top 10 of 25 ranked.

Pass Attempts

1997–2025

#	Player	Pass Att	Game	Detail
1	Sean Norris	54	Nov 3 2007 vs Carthage College	Cmp 26 · Yds 374 · TD 2 · Int 3
2	Mark Forcucci	53	Dec 13 2025 vs University of Wisconsin - River Falls	Cmp 27 · Yds 331 · TD 1 · Int 2
3	Josh Anderson	51	Oct 26 2002 vs Illinois Wesleyan University	Cmp 26 · Yds 381 · TD 4 · Int 3
4	Neil Anderson	50	Sep 23 2000 vs Hope College	Cmp 19 · Yds 260 · TD 2 · Int 5
4	Andrew Bowers	50	Nov 28 2015 vs University of Wisconsin-Whitewater	Cmp 26 · Yds 349 · TD 2 · Int 1
6	Sean Norris	49	Nov 14 2009 vs Carthage College	Cmp 25 · Yds 270 · TD 3 · Int 1
7	Johnny Peltz	48	Dec 3 2016 vs University of Mary Hardin-Baylor	Cmp 28 · Yds 284 · TD 2 · Int 3
8	Sean Norris	47	Nov 1 2008 vs Elmhurst University	Cmp 25 · Yds 259 · TD 2 · Int 3
8	Garrett Meador	47	Oct 1 2011 vs Illinois Wesleyan University	Cmp 26 · Yds 282 · TD 1 · Int 2
10	Chad Bradley	46	Sep 14 2002 vs Alma College	Cmp 27 · Yds 354 · TD 1 · Int 2

Top 10 of 25 ranked.

Rushing

Every era since 1914 · as published by Wheaton College Athletics

Rushing · Single-Game Records

Official

Record	Mark	Player	Game
Rushing Attempts	40	Bill Scholl	vs. Valparaiso, 11/16/68
Rushing Yards (Half)	287	Pedro Arruza	vs. North Central, 10/30/93
Rushing Yards (Game)	313	Pedro Arruza	vs. North Central, 10/30/93
Yards per Rush Attempt	21.2	Sola Olateju (8-170)	vs. Benedictine, 9/2/2017
Yards per Rush Attempt	20.9	Giovanni Weeks (8-167)	vs. Illinois Wesleyan, 11/6/2021
Yards per Rush Attempt	19.1	George MacKenzie (10-191)	vs. Millikin, 11/9/57
Rushing TDs	5	Chuck Schoenherr	vs. Lake Forest, 11/22/47
Longest TD Run	94	George MacKenzie	vs. Elmhurst, 9/26/56

Rushing Yards

1997–2025

#	Player	Yds	Game	Detail
1	Sola Olateju	273	Nov 11 2017 vs Carroll University	Att 25 · TD 4
2	Giovanni Weeks	268	Sep 24 2022 vs Augustana College (IL)	Att 37 · TD 0
3	Giovanni Weeks	256	Nov 18 2023 vs Mount St. Joseph University	Att 38 · TD 4
4	Brian Pastermack	220	Oct 14 2000 vs Carthage College	Att 20 · TD 2
5	Chaz Black	205	Oct 29 2005 vs Carthage College	Att 29 · TD 2
6	Dan Price	202	Oct 11 2003 vs Millikin University	Att 32 · TD 3
7	Sola Olateju	194	Nov 4 2017 vs Augustana College (IL)	Att 14 · TD 2
8	Sola Olateju	193	Oct 17 2015 vs Millikin University	Att 13 · TD 3
9	Chaz Black	191	Oct 7 2006 vs North Central College	Att 25 · TD 2
10	Garrett Granberg	190	Sep 11 2004 vs Gustavus Adolphus College	Att 21 · TD 2

Top 10 of 25 ranked.

Rushing Attempts

1997–2025

#	Player	Att	Game	Detail
1	Giovanni Weeks	38	Nov 18 2023 vs Mount St. Joseph University	Yds 256 · TD 4
2	Giovanni Weeks	37	Sep 24 2022 vs Augustana College (IL)	Yds 268 · TD 0
3	Rocky Gingg	36	Sep 11 2010 vs Albion College	Yds 185 · TD 1
4	Garrett Granberg	35	Sep 25 2004 vs Hope College	Yds 148 · TD 1
4	Rocky Gingg	35	Oct 11 2008 vs Augustana College (IL)	Yds 136 · TD 0
6	Dan Price	32	Oct 11 2003 vs Millikin University	Yds 202 · TD 3
6	Chaz Black	32	Sep 30 2006 vs Millikin University	Yds 146 · TD 0
8	Chaz Black	31	Oct 22 2005 vs Illinois Wesleyan University	Yds 107 · TD 0
8	Charlie Velling	31	Oct 17 2009 vs Millikin University	Yds 126 · TD 2
8	Brian Pastermack	31	Nov 11 2000 vs Augustana College (IL)	Yds 158 · TD 1

Top 10 of 25 ranked.

Rushing Touchdowns

1997–2025

#	Player	TD	Game	Detail
1	Brian Pastermack	4	Sep 18 1999 vs Anderson University (IN)	Att 16 · Yds 144
1	Garrett Granberg	4	Nov 13 2004 vs Augustana College (IL)	Att 21 · Yds 112
1	Andrew Hershey	4	Oct 21 2006 vs North Park University	Att 22 · Yds 115
1	Jordan Roberts	4	Sep 14 2013 vs Albion College	Att 14 · Yds 174
1	Johnny Peltz	4	Nov 1 2014 vs Elmhurst University	Att 16 · Yds 119
1	Sola Olateju	4	Nov 11 2017 vs Carroll University	Att 25 · Yds 273
1	Giovanni Weeks	4	Nov 6 2021 vs Illinois Wesleyan University	Att 8 · Yds 167
1	Giovanni Weeks	4	Nov 13 2021 vs Millikin University	Att 16 · Yds 114
1	Giovanni Weeks	4	Oct 28 2023 vs Millikin University	Att 10 · Yds 155
1	Giovanni Weeks	4	Nov 18 2023 vs Mount St. Joseph University	Att 38 · Yds 256

Top 10 of 25 ranked.

Longest Rush

1997–2025

#	Player	Longest Rush	Game	Detail
1	Sola Olateju	85	Oct 17 2015 vs Millikin University	Att 13 · Yds 193 · TD 3
1	Giovanni Weeks	85	Oct 28 2023 vs Millikin University	Att 10 · Yds 155 · TD 4
3	Sola Olateju	82	Sep 2 2017 vs Benedictine University	Att 8 · Yds 170 · TD 2
3	Cristian Carstens	82	Oct 15 2022 vs Carthage College	Att 14 · Yds 155 · TD 1
5	Jeremiah Tucker	81	Oct 23 2021 vs Carthage College	Att 8 · Yds 95 · TD 1
6	Chaz Black	80	Sep 23 2006 vs Hope College	Att 16 · Yds 126 · TD 1
7	Jacob Cretin	77	Sep 29 2018 vs North Central College	Att 16 · Yds 144 · TD 1
8	Sola Olateju	76	Nov 4 2017 vs Augustana College (IL)	Att 14 · Yds 194 · TD 2
9	Jaelin Goldsmith	75	Sep 29 2018 vs North Central College	Att 3 · Yds 71 · TD 1
9	Giovanni Weeks	75	Nov 6 2021 vs Illinois Wesleyan University	Att 8 · Yds 167 · TD 4

Top 10 of 25 ranked.

Receiving

Every era since 1914 · as published by Wheaton College Athletics

Receiving · Single-Game Records

Official

Record	Mark	Player	Game
Receptions	16	Mark Loeffler	vs. Mount Union, 11/25/95
Receptions	16	Pete Bylsma	vs. Millikin, 10/19/74
Receptions	16	Colin Sinclair	vs. Carthage, 10/30/2004
Receiving Yards	245	Mark Loeffler	vs. Mount Union, 11/25/95
Yards per Reception	58.3	Steve Thonn	vs. North Park, 10/9/82 (175-3)
TD Receptions	5	Caleb Titherington	vs. Carroll, 10/21/2023
TD Receptions	4	Mark Loeffler	vs. North Park, 11/2/96
TD Receptions	4	Teddy Watkins	vs. Millikin, 11/12/2011
Longest TD Reception	98	David Lauber	vs. North Central, 9/21/85

Receptions

1997–2025

#	Player	Receptions	Game	Detail
1	Colin Sinclair	16	Nov 6 2004 vs North Park University	Yds 194 · TD 2
2	Brad Musso	13	Sep 11 2004 vs Gustavus Adolphus College	Yds 138 · TD 1
2	Brad Musso	13	Sep 25 2004 vs Hope College	Yds 197 · TD 2
2	Colin Sinclair	13	Oct 30 2004 vs Carthage College	Yds 205 · TD 2
5	Jeremy Amos	12	Sep 9 2000 vs University of St. Francis (Ill.)	Yds 173 · TD 1
5	Brad Musso	12	Oct 9 2004 vs Millikin University	Yds 161 · TD 2
5	Mark Hiben	12	Nov 3 2012 vs North Central College	Yds 127 · TD 0
5	Phillip Nichols	12	Oct 13 2018 vs WashU	Yds 172 · TD 1
5	Ben Bonga	12	Sep 23 2023 vs Augustana College (IL)	Yds 143 · TD 1
5	Ben Peays	12	Sep 12 1998 vs WashU	Yds 153 · TD 1

Top 10 of 25 ranked.

Receiving Yards

1997–2025

#	Player	Yds	Game	Detail
1	Joe Chupp	217	Oct 8 2005 vs Millikin University	Rec 11 · TD 1
2	Phillip Nichols	207	Oct 5 2019 vs North Central College	Rec 10 · TD 3
3	Colin Sinclair	205	Oct 30 2004 vs Carthage College	Rec 13 · TD 2
4	Mark Hiben	204	Sep 29 2012 vs Augustana College (IL)	Rec 10 · TD 1
5	Ben Peays	202	Oct 24 1998 vs Illinois Wesleyan University	Rec 6 · TD 1
6	Seth Kortenhoeven	200	Oct 18 2025 vs Carthage College	Rec 9 · TD 2
7	Mark Hiben	198	Oct 13 2012 vs Elmhurst University	Rec 8 · TD 2
8	Brad Musso	197	Sep 25 2004 vs Hope College	Rec 13 · TD 2
9	Colin Sinclair	194	Nov 6 2004 vs North Park University	Rec 16 · TD 2
10	Brad Musso	185	Oct 19 2002 vs Carthage College	Rec 9 · TD 2

Top 10 of 25 ranked.

Receiving Touchdowns

1997–2025

#	Player	TD	Game	Detail
1	Caleb Titherington	5	Oct 21 2023 vs Carroll University	Rec 8 · Yds 113
2	Teddy Watkins	4	Nov 12 2011 vs Millikin University	Rec 8 · Yds 146
2	Ben Bonga	4	Oct 12 2024 vs Illinois Wesleyan University	Rec 8 · Yds 160
4	Brad Musso	3	Oct 13 2001 vs Carthage College	Rec 5 · Yds 122
4	Noah Dreyer	3	Sep 16 2006 vs WashU	Rec 9 · Yds 98
4	Joe Chupp	3	Nov 11 2006 vs Illinois Wesleyan University	Rec 5 · Yds 144
4	Alex Pokorny	3	Sep 20 2008 vs Concordia University (Wis.)	Rec 3 · Yds 140
4	Alex Pokorny	3	Nov 8 2008 vs Illinois Wesleyan University	Rec 6 · Yds 141
4	Mark Hiben	3	Oct 20 2012 vs Illinois Wesleyan University	Rec 8 · Yds 132
4	Luke Thorson	3	Oct 4 2014 vs North Park University	Rec 5 · Yds 79

Top 10 of 25 ranked.

Scoring

Every era since 1914 · as published by Wheaton College Athletics

Scoring · Single-Game Records

Official

Record	Mark	Player	Game
Touchdowns	5	Chuck Schoenherr	vs. Lake Forest, 11/22/47
Touchdowns	5	Caleb Titherington	vs. Carroll, 10/21/2023
Points	30	Chuck Schoenherr	vs. Lake Forest, 11/22/47
Points	30	Caleb Titherington	vs. Carroll, 10/21/2023

Points

1997–2025

#	Player	Points	Game	Detail
1	Caleb Titherington	30	Oct 21 2023 vs Carroll University	TD 5 · FGM 0 · FGA 0
2	Brian Pastermack	24	Sep 18 1999 vs Anderson University (IN)	TD 4 · FGM 0 · FGA 0
2	Garrett Granberg	24	Nov 13 2004 vs Augustana College (IL)	TD 4 · FGM 0 · FGA 0
2	Andrew Hershey	24	Oct 21 2006 vs North Park University	TD 4 · FGM 0 · FGA 0
2	Teddy Watkins	24	Nov 12 2011 vs Millikin University	TD 4 · FGM 0 · FGA 0
2	Jordan Roberts	24	Sep 14 2013 vs Albion College	TD 4 · FGM 0 · FGA 0
2	Johnny Peltz	24	Nov 1 2014 vs Elmhurst University	TD 4 · FGM 0 · FGA 0
2	Sola Olateju	24	Nov 11 2017 vs Carroll University	TD 4 · FGM 0 · FGA 0
2	Giovanni Weeks	24	Nov 6 2021 vs Illinois Wesleyan University	TD 4 · FGM 0 · FGA 0
2	Giovanni Weeks	24	Nov 13 2021 vs Millikin University	TD 4 · FGM 0 · FGA 0

Top 10 of 25 ranked.

Touchdowns

1997–2025

#	Player	TD	Game	Detail
1	Caleb Titherington	5	Oct 21 2023 vs Carroll University	FGM 0 · FGA 0 · Pts 30
2	Brian Pastermack	4	Sep 18 1999 vs Anderson University (IN)	FGM 0 · FGA 0 · Pts 24
2	Garrett Granberg	4	Nov 13 2004 vs Augustana College (IL)	FGM 0 · FGA 0 · Pts 24
2	Andrew Hershey	4	Oct 21 2006 vs North Park University	FGM 0 · FGA 0 · Pts 24
2	Teddy Watkins	4	Nov 12 2011 vs Millikin University	FGM 0 · FGA 0 · Pts 24
2	Jordan Roberts	4	Sep 14 2013 vs Albion College	FGM 0 · FGA 0 · Pts 24
2	Johnny Peltz	4	Nov 1 2014 vs Elmhurst University	FGM 0 · FGA 0 · Pts 24
2	Sola Olateju	4	Nov 11 2017 vs Carroll University	FGM 0 · FGA 0 · Pts 24
2	Giovanni Weeks	4	Nov 6 2021 vs Illinois Wesleyan University	FGM 0 · FGA 0 · Pts 24
2	Giovanni Weeks	4	Nov 13 2021 vs Millikin University	FGM 0 · FGA 0 · Pts 24

Top 10 of 25 ranked.

Returns

Every era since 1914 · as published by Wheaton College Athletics

Returns · Single-Game Records

Official

Record	Mark	Player	Game
Kickoff Returns	7	Clark Gilbert	vs. Millikin, 11/12/83
KO Return Yards	155	Brian Lazear	vs. Illinois Wesleyan, 9/21/91
Yards per KO Return	61.5	John Tuin	vs. Augustana, 11/13/79
Longest KO Return	100	John Tuin	vs. Augustana, 9/20/80
Punt Returns	8	Phillip Nichols	vs. Carroll, 11/11/2017
Punt Return Yards	157	Ed Davies	vs. Illinois College, 10/11/52
Longest Punt Return	94	Joel Detwiler	vs. DePauw, 9/16/67

Punt Return Yards

1997–2025

#	Player	Yds	Game	Detail
1	Pete Ittersagen	174	Nov 18 2006 vs Mount St. Joseph University	No 4 · TD 1
2	Mike Whalen	162	Oct 13 2001 vs Carthage College	No 8 · TD 0
3	Phillip Nichols	144	Sep 17 2016 vs Carthage College	No 6 · TD 1
4	Phillip Nichols	131	Nov 11 2017 vs Carroll University	No 8 · TD 0
5	Tyler Langs	124	Sep 18 2010 vs University of Wisconsin-Platteville	No 3 · TD 1
6	Pete Ittersagen	118	Sep 8 2007 vs Albion College	No 4 · TD 1
7	Ben Peays	113	Sep 18 1999 vs Anderson University (IN)	No 3 · TD 0
8	Pete Ittersagen	106	Sep 13 2008 vs Bethel University	No 3 · TD 1
9	Chaz Black	105	Sep 18 2004 vs Greenville University	No 7 · TD 1
10	Brad Musso	99	Nov 8 2003 vs North Park University	No 3 · TD 1

Top 10 of 25 ranked.

Kick Return Yards

1997–2025

#	Player	Yds	Game	Detail
1	Muhammad Weusi	173	Dec 6 2003 vs University of Mount Union	No 9 · TD 0
2	Eli Reeves	157	Oct 5 2024 vs North Central College	No 5 · TD 0
3	Teddy Watkins	153	Nov 5 2011 vs North Central College	No 5 · TD 0
4	Pete Ittersagen	150	Dec 6 2008 vs Franklin College	No 3 · TD 1
5	Jeremy Amos	149	Sep 23 2000 vs Hope College	No 5 · TD 0
6	Tim March	146	Oct 1 2005 vs North Central College	No 5 · TD 0
7	Bryant Wolfsberger	144	Sep 15 2001 vs Wabash College	No 4 · TD 1
8	Teddy Watkins	138	Sep 10 2011 vs Albion College	No 6 · TD 0
9	Teddy Watkins	135	Nov 20 2010 vs Coe College	No 4 · TD 0
10	Muhammad Weusi	134	Nov 22 2003 vs Hope College	No 6 · TD 0

Top 10 of 25 ranked.

Defense

Every era since 1914 · as published by Wheaton College Athletics

Defense · Single-Game Records

Official

Record	Mark	Player	Game
Longest INT Return	98	John Peays	vs. North Central, 9/26/98
Interceptions	3	Seven players

Total Tackles

1997–2025

#	Player	Total Tackles	Game	Detail
1	Greg McMillin	21	Sep 11 1999 vs WashU	Int 0
1	Greg McMillin	21	Nov 6 1999 vs Elmhurst University	Int 0
3	J.D. Leman	20	Oct 14 2000 vs Carthage College	Int 0
4	Adam Dansdill	19	Sep 20 2014 vs University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire	Int 0
4	J.D. Leman	19	Nov 11 2000 vs Augustana College (IL)	Int 0
6	Bryan Ittersagen	18	Sep 16 2000 vs Wabash College	Int 0
6	Justin Knapp	18	Sep 22 2001 vs Hope College	Int 0
6	Justin Knapp	18	Oct 20 2001 vs Illinois Wesleyan University	Int 0
6	Ben Wilson	18	Nov 14 1998 vs Augustana College (IL)	Int 0
10	Jeff Grandy	17	Oct 8 2005 vs Millikin University	Int 1

Top 10 of 25 ranked.

Sacks

1997–2025

#	Player	Sacks	Game	Detail
1	Shawn Wildt	6.0	Oct 23 1999 vs Illinois Wesleyan University	Int 0
2	Chase Greenlee	5.0	Nov 11 2017 vs Carroll University	Int 0
3	Dane Lundgren	4.0	Sep 14 2002 vs Alma College	Int 0
4	River Shindledecker	3.5	Oct 26 2019 vs Augustana College (IL)	Int 0
4	Jake Holaday	3.5	Oct 16 2021 vs Carroll University	Int 0
4	Peter Johanik	3.5	Nov 9 2024 vs Millikin University	Int 0
7	Dane Lundgren	3.0	Nov 23 2002 vs Alma College	Int 0
7	Tim Cryer	3.0	Nov 1 2003 vs North Central College	Int 0
7	Andy Studebaker	3.0	Oct 7 2006 vs North Central College	Int 0
7	Andy Studebaker	3.0	Sep 22 2007 vs Hope College	Int 0

Top 10 of 25 ranked.

Tackles for Loss

1997–2025

#	Player	Tackles for Loss	Game	Detail
1	Peter Johanik	6.0	Nov 9 2024 vs Millikin University	Int 0
2	Chase Greenlee	5.0	Nov 11 2017 vs Carroll University	Int 0
2	Dallas McRae	5.0	Oct 30 2021 vs Elmhurst University	Int 0
4	Andy Studebaker	4.5	Oct 1 2005 vs North Central College	Int 0
4	Andy Studebaker	4.5	Oct 22 2005 vs Illinois Wesleyan University	Int 0
4	Luke Sahly	4.5	Sep 16 2017 vs Carthage College	Int 0
4	River Shindledecker	4.5	Oct 26 2019 vs Augustana College (IL)	Int 0
8	Drew Pearson	4.0	Sep 11 1999 vs WashU	Int 0
8	Drew Pearson	4.0	Nov 6 1999 vs Elmhurst University	Int 0
8	James Busch	4.0	Nov 4 2000 vs North Park University	Int 0

Top 10 of 25 ranked.

Interceptions

1997–2025

#	Player	Interceptions	Game
1	Tyler Langs	3	Oct 30 2010 vs Augustana College (IL)
2	Mitch Clement	2	Sep 11 1999 vs WashU
2	John Peays	2	Oct 9 1999 vs Carthage College
2	Ryan McCaffrey	2	Oct 14 2000 vs Carthage College
2	Bob Bollweg	2	Sep 15 2001 vs Wabash College
2	Bob Bollweg	2	Sep 29 2001 vs North Central College
2	Ty Gose	2	Nov 22 2003 vs Hope College
2	Todd Travis	2	Sep 10 2005 vs Gustavus Adolphus College
2	Pete Ittersagen	2	Oct 8 2005 vs Millikin University
2	Pete Ittersagen	2	Sep 16 2006 vs WashU

Top 10 of 25 ranked.

Interception Return Yards

1997–2025

#	Player	Yds	Game	Detail
1	Tyler Langs	102	Oct 30 2010 vs Augustana College (IL)	No 3 · TD 0
2	John Peays	98	Oct 3 1998 vs North Central College	No 1 · TD 1
3	Corey Kennedy	96	Sep 7 2019 vs Monmouth College	No 2 · TD 0
4	Tyler Sigler	95	Sep 2 2017 vs Benedictine University	No 1 · TD 0
5	Wes Cannonier	92	Sep 19 2015 vs University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire	No 2 · TD 0
6	Jackson Edwards	81	Sep 14 2013 vs Albion College	No 1 · TD 0
7	Bryan McBroom	78	Sep 18 2010 vs University of Wisconsin-Platteville	No 1 · TD 1
8	J.D. Leman	73	Oct 28 2000 vs Elmhurst University	No 1 · TD 0
9	Pete Ittersagen	72	Nov 5 2005 vs North Park University	No 1 · TD 1
10	Adam Dansdill	70	Sep 15 2012 vs Luther College	No 1 · TD 0

Top 10 of 25 ranked.

Kicking

Every era since 1914 · as published by Wheaton College Athletics

Kicking · Single-Game Records

Official

Record	Mark	Player	Game
PATs	10	Tim Ellingsen	vs. North Park, 10/21/2006
PATs	10	Griffin Bowes	vs. Elmhurst, 11/10/18
Field Goals	5	Bob Unruh	vs. Millikin, 10/22/77
Longest Field Goal	53	Sam Cote	vs. Illinois Wesleyan, 10/26/2013
Field Goal Attempts	6	Bob Unruh	vs. Millikin, 10/22/77

Field Goals Made

1997–2025

#	Player	Field Goals Made	Game	Detail
1	Tim Ellingsen	4	Oct 11 2008 vs Augustana College (IL)	FGA 4
1	Scott Roche	4	Oct 30 2010 vs Augustana College (IL)	FGA 4
1	Stefan Knoerr	4	Sep 23 2017 vs Elmhurst University	FGA 4
4	Chris Baughman	3	Oct 2 1999 vs North Central College	FGA 3
4	Chris Baughman	3	Oct 9 1999 vs Carthage College	FGA 3
4	Andrew Day	3	Oct 4 2003 vs Elmhurst University	FGA 3
4	Andrew Day	3	Sep 10 2005 vs Gustavus Adolphus College	FGA 3
4	Scott Roche	3	Nov 14 2009 vs Carthage College	FGA 3
4	Scott Roche	3	Sep 11 2010 vs Albion College	FGA 4
4	Scott Roche	3	Sep 18 2010 vs University of Wisconsin-Platteville	FGA 4

Top 10 of 25 ranked.

Punting

Every era since 1914 · as published by Wheaton College Athletics

Punting · Single-Game Records

Official

Record	Mark	Player	Game
Punts	14	Greg Holmgren	vs. Washington (Mo.), 10/6/79
Punt Yards	530	Greg Holmgren	vs. Washington (Mo.), 10/6/79
Longest Punt	74	Greg Holmgren	vs. North Central, 11/3/79
Punt Avg. (5+ Punts)	50.5	John White (6-303)	vs. Carroll, 9/20/69

Punting Average

min. 3 attempts1997–2025

#	Player	Punting Average	Game	Detail
1	Josiah Smith	56.3	Oct 11 2025 vs Illinois Wesleyan University	No 3 · Yds 169
2	Zach Feddeler	50.4	Oct 7 2017 vs Millikin University	No 5 · Yds 252
3	Sam Cote	48.7	Sep 15 2012 vs Luther College	No 3 · Yds 146
4	Nate Tofilon	48.0	Nov 4 2023 vs WashU	No 3 · Yds 144
5	John Bickle	47.8	Sep 18 2021 vs North Central College	No 4 · Yds 191
6	Zach Feddeler	47.7	Sep 29 2018 vs North Central College	No 3 · Yds 143
7	Josiah Smith	46.3	Dec 6 2025 vs DePauw University	No 3 · Yds 139
8	Josiah Smith	46.2	Sep 6 2025 vs University of Mount Union	No 4 · Yds 185
9	Zach Feddeler	45.7	Oct 3 2015 vs North Park University	No 3 · Yds 137
10	Sean Norris	45.3	Oct 7 2006 vs North Central College	No 3 · Yds 136

Top 10 of 25 ranked.