| 1914 | Jasper Turnbull | 1-6 | | | Jack Conley |
| 1915 | Jasper Turnbull | 5-2 | | | Art Twigg |
| 1916 | Bob Robinson | 1-5 | | | Jack Conley |
| 1917 | No Coach | 2-4 | | | Chuck Meebold |
| 1918 | No Team | | | | |
| 1919 | Rex Gary | 2-3 | | | Chuck Meebold |
| 1920 | Rex Gary | 4-3 | | | Orland Stockton |
| 1921 | Bob Woodruff | 6-2 | | | Orland Stockton |
| 1922 | Jack Conley | 6-2 | | | Orland Stockton |
| 1923 | Jack Conley | 2-3-2 | | | Jim Wolstenholme |
| 1924 | Jack Conley | 4-3 | | | Jim Wolstenholme |
| 1925 | Dave Gillespie | 1-7 | | | Victor Hicks, Wes McGill |
| 1926 | Ed Coray | 0-6-1 | | | Evan Welsh |
| 1927 | Ed Coray | 2-4-1 | | | Donald Guild |
| 1928 | Ed Coray | 3-4-1 | | | Dunham Reinig |
| 1929 | Vic Gustafson | 2-6-1 | | | Clarence Rhoades |
| 1930 | Vic Gustafson | 2-6 | | | Lewis McGill |
| 1931 | Vic Gustafson | 3-5 | | | Arlyn Bartholomew |
| 1932 | Vic Gustafson | 4-3 | | | Willard Bell |
| 1933 | Vic Gustafson | 2-2-3 | | | Carl Olander |
| 1934 | Vic Gustafson | 1-5-1 | | | Bob Glover |
| 1935 | Wendel Smith | 2-5-1 | | | Del Nelson |
| 1936 | Fred Walker | 3-2-2 | | | Doug Johnston |
| 1937 | Fred Walker | 3-5 | | | James McDonald |
| 1938 | Fred Walker | 3-3 | | | William Gavin |
| 1939 | Fred Walker | 2-4-2 | | | LeRoy Patterson |
| 1940 | Harve Chrouser | 1-6-1 | | | Julius Voget |
| 1941 | Harve Chrouser | 3-5-2 | | | Ralph Glatfelter, Harlan Harris |
| 1942 | Albert Graf | 5-3-1 | | | Val Oleari |
| 1943 | Carl DeVries | 3-0-3 | | | Verne Koppin |
| 1944 | Carl DeVries | 5-1 | | | Dave Norbeck, Bill Shaffer |
| 1945 | Carl DeVries | 3-4 | | | Dick Hills, Dave Norbeck |
| 1946 | Harve Chrouser | 6-2 | 3-1 | | Mel Lyons, Bob Whitaker |
| 1947 | Harve Chrouser | 7-1-1 | 4-1 | | Bill Guy, Chuck Schoenherr |
| 1948 | Harve Chrouser | 6-2 | 4-1 | | Bob Blaschke, jack Mayhall |
| 1949 | Harve Chrouser | 8-2 | 5-0 | CCIW Co-Champions | Don Brinks, Wendy Loveless |
| 1950 | Harve Chrouser | 7-2 | 5-0 | CCIW Champions | Jack Lockhart, Jack Swartz |
| 1951 | Harve Chrouser | 6-2 | 3-1 | | Jay McCully, Jack Swartz |
| 1952 | Harve Chrouser | 7-1 | 4-1 | | Eddie Mitchell, Les Story |
| 1953 | Harve Chrouser | 8-1 | 4-0 | CCIW Champions | Ed Davies, Jerry Snyder |
| 1954 | Harve Chrouser | 6-2 | 5-1 | CCIW Co-Champions | Dick Helm, Tom Byron |
| 1955 | Harve Chrouser | 6-1-1 | 5-0-1 | CCIW Champions | Dave Burnham, Dick Holt |
| 1956 | Harve Chrouser | 7-1 | 7-0 | CCIW Champions | Fred Brock, Carl Couch |
| 1957 | Harve Chrouser | 8-1 | 6-1 | CCIW Co-Champions | Dick Camp, Rodger Johnson |
| 1958 | Harve Chrouser | 8-0 | 7-0 | CCIW Champions | Bob Bakke, Bill Hoppel |
| 1959 | Harve Chrouser | 6-1-2 | 6-0-1 | CCIW Champions | Don Brock, Steve Murray |
| 1960 | Harve Chrouser | 4-4-1 | | | Dan Branda, Bruce Whipple |
| 1961 | Jack Swartz | 8-0 | | | Dave Iha, George Kraft |
| 1962 | Jack Swartz | 5-4 | | | Dave Kemna, Walt Wolfram |
| 1963 | Jack Swartz | 8-1 | | | Dave Borgman, Albie Harris |
| 1964 | Jack Swartz | 2-7 | | | Jim Kielmeier, Dick Taylor |
| 1965 | Jack Swartz | 1-8 | | | Bob Bennett, Dale Lehmer |
| 1966 | Jack Swartz | 5-4 | | | Dave McDowell, Stu Webber |
| 1967 | Jack Swartz | 7-2 | | | Ross Anderson, Dave McDowell |
| 1968 | Jack Swartz | 5-4 | | | Levi Edgecombe, Ken Wagner |
| 1969 | Mal Pearson | 3-6 | | | Joel Detwiler, Steve Myers |
| 1970 | Mal Pearson | 1-7-1 | 1-6-1 | | Walt Bate, Bud Ortlund |
| 1971 | Gary Taylor | 1-8 | 1-7 | | Dave Ferwerda |
| 1972 | Gary Taylor | 1-8 | 1-7 | | Dave Ferwerda, Mike Sedjo |
| 1973 | Dewey King | 2-7 | 2-6 | | Tom Bleed, Mike Sedjo |
| 1974 | Dewey King | 4-5 | 4-4 | | Wayne Gordon, Art Nitz |
| 1975 | Dewey King | 5-4 | 5-3 | | John Duncan, Dan Ferwerda |
| 1976 | Dewey King | 6-3 | 5-3 | | Jim Bowen, Glenn Sedjo |
| 1977 | Dewey King | 5-4 | 4-4 | | Kevin Blusher, Larry Wagner |
| 1978 | Dewey King | 6-3 | 5-3 | | Scott Hall, Hutsie Hertzberg |
| 1979 | Dewey King | 1-8 | 1-7 | | Brad Hall, Greg Holmgren |
| 1980 | C. Schimmels | 2-7 | 1-7 | | Paul Atwater, Jeff Peltz |
| 1981 | Jim Rexilius | 2-7 | 1-7 | | Jasper Bacon, Doug Munton |
| 1982 | J.R. Bishop | 2-7 | 2-6 | | Dave McCarrell, Jon Tuin |
| 1983 | J.R. Bishop | 6-3 | 5-3 | | Brad Benson, Dave Plaep |
| 1984 | J.R. Bishop | 6-3 | 5-3 | | Rob Martin, Dave Prescher, Mark Seeland |
| 1985 | J.R. Bishop | 6-3 | 6-2 | | Rick Fox, Ernie Frey, Matt Seeland |
| 1986 | J.R. Bishop | 7-2 | 6-2 | | Rod Duttweiler, Ernie Frey |
| 1987 | J.R. Bishop | 3-6 | 2-6 | | Tom Nussbaum, Curt Trampe |
| 1988 | J.R. Bishop | 7-2 | 6-2 | | Ben Furman, Andy McGown |
| 1989 | J.R. Bishop | 6-3 | 5-3 | | Steve Holland, Jeff Lane, Don Parrish, Chad Thorson |
| 1990 | J.R. Bishop | 4-5 | 4-4 | | Mark Neibch, Rod Sandberg |
| 1991 | J.R. Bishop | 7-1-1 | 6-1-1 | | Chris Davis, Jeff Frazier, Steve Nitz |
| 1992 | J.R. Bishop | 6-3 | 5-2 | | Bart Moseman, Tim Tully |
| 1993 | J.R. Bishop | 7-6 | 6-1 | | Jim Johanik, Neal Neathery |
| 1994 | J.R. Bishop | 7-2 | 5-2 | | Jason Noble, Matt Stier |
| 1995 | J.R. Bishop | 10-1 | 7-0 | CCIW Champions NCAA Division III Playoffs | Pedro Arruza, Jeff Brown, David Hoover, Doug Johnson, Todd Ritzman |
| 1996 | Mike Swider | 8-1 | 6-1 | | Wes Mooring, Chip Parrish |
| 1997 | Mike Swider | 4-5 | 4-3 | | Chris Brown |
| 1998 | Mike Swider | 6-3 | 5-2 | | Tim Hardy, Jerry Hawkes |
| 1999 | Mike Swider | 7-2 | 5-2 | | Collin Quin, Drew Pearson, Mitch Clement |
| 2000 | Mike Swider | 8-2 | 6-1 | CCIW Co-Champions | Jeremy Amos, Greg McMillin, Darryn Wiebe, Brian Pastermack |
| 2001 | Mike Swider | 6-4 | 5-2 | | Jon Adams, Jamie Busch, Ryan McCaffery |
| 2002 | Mike Swider | 10-2 | 7-0 | CCIW Champions NCAA Division III Playoffs | Justin Knapp, Dane Lundgren, Corey Noonan |
| 2003 | Mike Swider | 12-1 | 7-0 | CCIW Champions NCAA Division III Playoffs | Chad Bradley, Ty Gose, James Hoxworth, Jeff Mumm |
| 2004 | Mike Swider | 10-2 | 6-1 | CCIW Co-Champions NCAA Division III Playoffs | Mark Hamstra, Tim Cryer, Jeff Grandy, Brian Dini |
| 2005 | Mike Swider | 7-3 | 4-3 | | Luke Bazacas, Jeff Grandy, Kelly Stewart, Todd Travis |
| 2006 | Mike Swider | 10-2 | 6-1 | CCIW Co-Champions NCAA Division III Playoffs | Jonathan Toal, Tim March, Brad Thornton, Chaz Black |
| 2007 | Mike Swider | 8-2 | 6-2 | | Chriss Fossum, Mike McKinney, Andy Studebaker |
| 2008 | Mike Swider | 11-3 | 5-2 | NCAA Division III Playoffs | Alex Pokorny, Kyle Bradley, Mike McKinney, Shane Woodward |
| 2009 | Mike Swider | 7-3 | 4-3 | | Sean Norris, Mike Berttucci, Steven Lutes |
| 2010 | Mike Swider | 10-2 | 6-1 | NCAA Division III Playoffs | Kyle Notch, Nick Biggee, Teddy Watkins, Jordan Chapman |
| 2011 | Mike Swider | 8-2 | 5-2 | | Jordan Chapman, Teddy Watkins, Brannen Dorman, Brian McMullen, Robert Ramsay |
| 2012 | Mike Swider | 8-2 | 6-1 | CCIW Co-Champions | Garrett Meador, Peter Jarrett, Pat Dansdill, Sam VanHeest |
| 2013 | Mike Swider | 8-2 | 5-2 | | Brett Anderson, Nolan Randall, Jordan Roberts, Sam Weatherred |
| 2014 | Mike Swider | 11-1 | 7-0 | CCIW Champions NCAA Division III Playoffs | Reece Butler, Jesse Geary, Jesse Todd, Mitch Warren |
| 2015 | Mike Swider | 11-1 | 7-0 | CCIW Champions NCAA Division III Playoffs | Josh Aldrin, Adam Dansdill, Danny Puknaitis, Matt Snebold |
| 2016 | Mike Swider | 11-2 | 7-1 | NCAA Division III Playoffs | Caleb Ashby, Daniel Gray, Peter Gibson, Johnny Peltz |
| 2017 | Mike Swider | 8-2 | 6-2 | | Jon Callaway, Daniel Gray, Curtis McWilliams, Marcus Smith |
| 2018 | Mike Swider | 8-2 | 7-2 | | Kyle Fox, Andrew Jones, Curtis McWilliams, Tyler Sigler, Eric Stevenson |
| 2019 | Mike Swider | 12-1 | 9-0 | CCIW Champions NCAA Division III Playoffs | Daniel Herber, Corey Kennedy, Phillip Nichols, Patrick O'Connell, Adam Terrini |
| 2020 | | | | | Season canceled due to COVID-19 pandemic |
| 2021 | Jesse Scott | 10-2 | 8-1 | NCAA Division III Playoffs | Luke Anthony, Daniel Herber, Wyatt Lee, Gabriel McGill, Ryan Schwartz, Adam Terrini |
| 2022 | Jesse Scott | 8-3 | 8-1 | NCAA Division III Playoffs | Sam Bell, Kyle Carter, Trevor Gabriele, Caleb Kuhn |
| 2023 | Jesse Scott | 10-2 | 8-1 | NCAA Division III Playoffs | Trevor Gabriele, Clayton Reeves, JJ Ruff, Riley Schwartz |
| 2024 | Jesse Scott | 9-2 | 8-1 | Culver's Isthmus Bowl Champions | Ben Bonga, Xaviere Jones, Caleb McClung, Riley Schwartz |
